Fri. November 28, 2014 Get Published  Get Alerts
HOME  |LOGIN
ABOUT | CONTACT US | SUPPORT US
Our Collective Failure

Comments(0)
By Pratik Patil


We are running out of time to contain Global warming within scientifically recommended and internationally acknowledged safe limits of 2oC. Our planet is approaching the threshold beyond which it will be extremely difficult to prevent disastrous consequences of human induced climate change.

This is the underlying conclusion of string of recent study reports by major international agencies.

The World Bank report titled 'Turn down the Heat'1 cites that there's nearly unanimous agreement among scientists that "countries? current United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change emission pledges and commitments would most likely result in 3.5-4°C warming.? The 4°C scenarios are devastating: the inundation of coastal cities; increasing risks for food production potentially leading to higher malnutrition rates; many dry regions becoming dryer, wet regions wetter; unprecedented heat waves in many regions, especially in the tropics; substantially exacerbated water scarcity in many regions; increased frequency of high-intensity tropical cyclones; and irreversible loss of biodiversity, including coral reef systems.

(For sake of perspective, it is useful to note that 4°C is the difference between temperatures today and those of the last ice age. And current rate of change in temperatures is stupendously faster than any time during Earth's recent history)

More worryingly, Third Emissions Gap Report2 by UN Environment Programme (UNEP) demonstrates that countries are failing to meet even these moderate and inadequate pledges to reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions, by wide margins. In fact, each successive emissions gap report since 2010 has shown an increase in the gap between projections and pledges of CO2 Emissions. The latest figures from the Global Carbon Project, 3 show that global emissions have been growing at an average of 3 per cent each year since 2000.

Other studies4 are showing that IPCC assessment reports under-estimated scale of potential temperature changes by failing to account for runaway effects of melting in Arctic regions, resulting in enormous CO2 and methane releases trapped by permafrost.

Seen in this context, COP-18 agreement in Doha, to extend Kyoto Protocol (which is restricted to countries whose share of global emissions is less than 15%; with big polluters like US, China, Russia and Canada excluded) up to 2020, is clearly too little and too late. It is the final death knell to hopes of achieving reasonable climate change mitigation.

As the delegate from Seychelles put it (while speaking to BBC), "We're past the mitigation [emissions cuts] and adaptation eras. We're now right into the era of loss and damage."

On a slightly positive note, there was one potentially significant "agreement in principle" that rich countries should compensate poor, vulnerable countries for damages due to climate change. This is an implicit admission of guilt on behalf of rich polluters. But in the absence of meaningful enforcement mechanism at the international level, there's not much substance in it. Like they've done before, rich countries can simply walk away from any ‘binding’ commitments without impunity (one such example is, US and Canadian departure from Kyoto protocol).

What is the reason behind our dismal failure to heed scientific warnings on climate change?

At the fundamental level, I think there's huge lag between exponential rate of technological revolution (roughly dictated by famous Moore's law) and our comparatively linear, moral evolution. End result is that, although we are technically masters of the planet, we lack wisdom to be good shepherds.

Climate change is but one such example of our collective failure to evolve.

In his book, World on the Edge5, eminent environmentalist Lester R Brown notes, ?”A 2002 study by a team of scientists aggregated the use of the earth’s natural assets, into a single indicator: the ecological footprint. The authors concluded that humanity’s collective demands first surpassed the earth’s regenerative capacity around 1980. By 1999, global demands on the earth’s natural systems exceeded sustainable yields by 20 %. On-going calculations show it at 50 % in 2007. Stated otherwise, it would take 1.5 Earths to sustain our current consumption. Environmentally, the world is in overshoot mode.”?

Yet, as underpinned by response to current financial crisis, our utmost concern is not how to achieve sustainable development (i.e. development that ?meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs") but to ensure perpetual GDP growth at all costs.

Lester R Brown presents us with thought provoking question:

“How can we assume that the growth of an economic system that is shrinking the earth’s forests, eroding its soils, depleting its aquifers, collapsing its fisheries, elevating its temperature, and melting its ice sheets can simply be projected into the long-term future? What is the intellectual process underpinning these extrapolations?”

Our failure to combat climate change and wider sustainability challenges with traditional ‘economic’ solutions should compel us to fundamentally rethink our dependence on perpetual economic growth paradigm. For example, under the current economic regime, GDP growth is essential for employment generation. But with over 50% youth unemployment in countries like Spain, it’s high time that we take radically different course. Reducing work hours to accommodate more people in the workforce could be one solution. This may seem radical but we need to start thinking about these options seriously to overcome our current predicament, in which neither human societies nor natural systems are coping well.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. http://climatechange.worldbank.org/sites/default/files/Turn_Down_the_Heat_Executive_Summary_English.pdf
2. http://www.unep.org/publications/ebooks/emissionsgap2012/
3. http://www.globalcarbonproject.org/carbonbudget/12/hl-compact.htm
4. http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn22549-arctic-permafrost-is-melting-faster-than-predicted.html
5. http://www.earth-policy.org/books/wote
6. http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/the-desertec-solar-energy-project-has-run-into-trouble-a-867077.html
7. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20002801


Pratik Patil is an analyst with IA-Forum's international affairs division.
email - pratik.p.patil@gmail.com


Comments in Chronological order (0 total comments)

Report Abuse
Quick Links Twitter Face Book Get Alerts Contact Us Enter Ia-Forum Student Award Competition
International Affairs
Forum - (2014 Issue 1)

Available Now
ANNOUNCEMENTS
THE WORLD'S DISCUSSING...
11/28/2014: Financial Regionalism and the International Monetary System More
11/28/2014: Fiscal Therapy: A Rehab Program for America's Addiction to Debt More
11/28/2014: Financial Regionalism and the International Monetary System More
11/27/2014: Some Perspective on What We Have to Be Thankful For More
11/26/2014: Development blog: Alex Cobham’s Off to the Tax Justice Network More
11/26/2014: Teyise Dlamini Tells the United Nations, Children are the Future More
11/26/2014: NSA Reform -- The Consequences of Failure More
11/26/2014: U.S. Filled Okinawa with Bases and Japan Kept Them There: Okinawans Again Say No More
11/26/2014: Happy Thanksgiving from Cato More
11/26/2014: Obama’s Overshadowed Start-up Gambit More
11/26/2014: India’s Role in the International Climate Negotiations More
11/26/2014: Congressman William Frenzel: A Mountain of Humility More
11/26/2014: Iran Nuclear Talks: For Europe, Roll-Over Is Better than Game Over More
11/26/2014: Hutchins Roundup: Tax Revenue, Decentralizations, and More More
11/26/2014: Hutchins Roundup: Tax Revenue, Decentralizations, and More More
11/26/2014: The Uniquely Widespread Presidential Campaign of Rand Paul More
11/25/2014: Global Health blog: Realizing the Vision of Swasth Bharat through Fiscal Federalism in India More
11/25/2014: France’s and Italy’s New ‘Tony Blairs’: Third Way or No Way? More
11/25/2014: WATCH: Robert Einhorn Explains Status of P5+1–Iran Nuclear Negotiations More
11/25/2014: Development blog: Should Sovereign Wealth Funds Finance Domestic Investment? More
11/25/2014: Development blog: World AIDS Day 2014: UNAIDS Shifts Its Emphasis toward Reducing New Infections More
11/25/2014: Global Health blog: World AIDS Day 2014: UNAIDS Shifts Its Emphasis toward Reducing New Infections More
11/25/2014: The US-China Climate Deal: Not a Free Ride for the Chinese More
11/25/2014: Iran-P5+1 Nuclear Negotiations: The Road Ahead More
11/25/2014: China Takes another Step toward Capital Freedom More
11/25/2014: CGD Event: Winners and Losers of Globalization: Political Implications of Inequality More
11/24/2014: Development blog: All Technology Leapfrogging Is Not the Same (Why Phones ? Energy) More
11/24/2014: Development blog: ‘Taxing across Borders’: An Academic Milestone More
11/24/2014: Police Misconduct, in Ferguson and Beyond More
11/24/2014: Bury Lenin's Body and the Rest of Communism: In Red Square He Lies in State, Mocking Humanity More
11/24/2014: Safeguarding the Role of Displaced Communities in Decisions about Relocations More
11/24/2014: Safeguarding the Role of Displaced Communities in Decisions about Relocations More
11/24/2014: America's Dangerous Double Standard on Air and Sea "Provocations" More
11/24/2014: Going Overboard at the Labor Board More
11/24/2014: Reviving Growth: A Cato Online Forum More
11/22/2014: NAGPRA, Indian Burials, and the Unquiet Grave More
11/22/2014: The School Religious Holidays Problem Is Really a Public Schooling Problem More
11/21/2014: Development blog: Trade Growth Is Slowing; Is Protectionism to Blame? More
11/21/2014: Obama’s Act Gives Hope to Four Million Immigrants, but More is Needed More
11/21/2014: Cuba’s Foreign Investment Invitation: Insights into Internal Struggles More
11/21/2014: How Places Can Make the Executive Actions on Immigration Work More
11/21/2014: Republican Division on an Immigration Response Highlights a GOP Challenge More
11/21/2014: Currency Wars, the Ruble and Keynes More
11/21/2014: Inequality and Envy More
11/21/2014: Bad Laws Lead to Bad Executive Orders More
11/21/2014: Bring China and Its Neighbors Under the INF Missile Treaty More
11/21/2014: A Perplexing Foreign Policy More
11/21/2014: NSA Reform: Not Dead Yet More
11/21/2014: CGD Publication: To Charge or Not to Charge: Evidence from a Health Products Experiment in Uganda - Working Paper 387 More
11/20/2014: Obama’s Immigration Order Isn’t a Power Grab More
More...
About | Contact Us | Support Us | Terms and Conditions

All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2002 - 2014