X Welcome to International Affairs Forum

International Affairs Forum a platform to encourage a more complete understanding of the world's opinions on international relations and economics. It presents a cross-section of all-partisan mainstream content, from left to right and across the world.

By reading International Affairs Forum, not only explore pieces you agree with but pieces you don't agree with. Read the other side, challenge yourself, analyze, and share pieces with others. Most importantly, analyze the issues and discuss them civilly with others.

And, yes, send us your essay or editorial! Students are encouraged to participate.

Please enter and join the many International Affairs Forum participants who seek a better path toward addressing world issues.
Mon. December 17, 2018
Get Published   |   About Us   |   Support Us   | Login
International Affairs Forum
Social Media
Regional Security Architectures: Comparing Asia and Europe
Comments (15)

Trans-Pacific View author Mercy Kuo regularly engages subject-matter experts, policy practitioners, and strategic thinkers across the globe for their diverse insights into U.S. Asia policy. This conversation with Dr. Anis Bajrektarevic—chairperson and professor in international law and global political studies in Vienna, Austria and editor of the New York-based scientific journal Geopolitics, History, and International Relations—is the 98th in “The Trans-Pacific View Insight Series.”

 

Compare and contrast regional security architectures in Asia and Europe.

While all other major theaters have already had pan-continental settings in place for many decades, such as the Organization of American States—OAS (American continent); African Union—AU (Africa); Council of Europe and Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe—OSCE (Europe), Asia is rather different. What becomes apparent, at first glance, is the absence of any pan-Asian security or multilateral structure. Prevailing security structures are bilateral and mostly asymmetric. They range from the clearly defined and enduring non-aggression security treaties, through less formal arrangements, up to the ad hoc cooperation accords on specific issues.

The presence of the multilateral regional settings is limited to a very few spots in the largest continent, and even then, they are rarely mandated with security issues in their declared scope of work.

Another striking feature is that most of the existing bilateral structures have an Asian state on one side, and an either peripheral or external protégé country on the other side. This makes them nearly, by definition, asymmetric. The examples are numerous: the US–Japan, US–South Korea, US–Singapore, Russia–India, Australia–East Timor, Russia–North Korea, Japan–Malaysia, China–Pakistan, US–Pakistan, China–Cambodia, US–Saudi Arabia, Russia–Iran, China–Burma, India–Maldives, Iran–Syria, North Korea–Pakistan, and so on.

With Brexit in the United Kingdom and the “America First” foreign policy of the United States, please give us your take on the future of NATO.

The West is apparently in a serious decline. The United Kingdom has been sliding down for 100 years, absorbed by a skillful set of planetary contrasts. The United States has been melting ever since the end of WWII. In 1945, Americans produced 54 percent of the global manufacturing output, and today it is barely 1/3 of it.

NATO is a relic of Cold War instrumentarium. Currently, confrontational nostalgia is what keeps it afloat. The Atlantistic world is overcommitted and overstretched. London and Washington understand that NATO is increasingly becoming part of the problem—not the solution to their future. Europe goes along with it. Simply, the Old Continent is not a wealthy club anymore. It is a theater with a memory of its wealthy past. The EU has to learn how to deescalate and compromise. This is in its best interest, for the sake of its only viable future.   

Is an Asian version of NATO plausible?     

Why must the world’s largest continent consider the creation of a comprehensive pan-Asian institution? Not a military pact a’la NATO (since NATO is only an instrument of American military presence in Europe) but a true multi-vector and multilateral instrument. Prevailing security structures in Asia are bilateral and mostly asymmetric, while Europe enjoys multilateral, balanced, and symmetric setups (just like the American and African continents).

In my forthcoming book No Asian Century, I go as far as to claim that, irrespective of the impressive economic growth, no Asian century will emerge without the creation of such an institution. Asia today is an immense, running water without clear riverbanks: a rising economic success, but a social volcano and political hazard.

Identify three ongoing geopolitical risks that Asia and Europe share.

For most of the nineteenth and a good part of twentieth century, a central question of Europe and the Euro-Atlantic was how many ‘Germanys’ Europe can digest—one big, über-performing, and omnipresent Germany, or several Germanophone states in a dynamic equilibrium with itself and the rest. This and the so-called ‘grand accommodation’—Germany with Russia or France with Russia—will remain a central security dilemma for many decades to come.

On the other side of the world, the entire Asian architecture was based on an assumption of a weak center:  fragmented, backward and soft mainland China. What we are witnessing now is awaking of China—reminiscent of an imperial Germany in the heart of Europe.  

What common linkages underpin U.S. transatlantic and transpacific relations, and how should the U.S. administration capitalize on them?

China’s grab for fossil fuels or its military competition for naval control is not a challenge but rather a boost for the US Asia-Pacific—even an overall posture. Calibrating the contraction of its overseas projection and commitments, or, managing the decline of an empire, the US does not fail to note that nowadays half of the world’s merchant tonnage passes though the South China Sea. Therefore, the US will exploit any regional territorial dispute and other frictions to its own security benefit, including the costs sharing of its military presence with the local partners to maintain its pivotal position on the maritime edge of Asia that arches from the Persian Gulf to the Indian Ocean, Malacca, the South and East China Sea, and up to the northwest–central Pacific.  

A real challenge is to always optimize the moral, political and financial costs in meeting national strategic objectives. In this case, it would be a resolute Beijing’s turn towards green technology, coupled with the firm buildup of Asian multilateralism. Without a grand rapprochement to the champions of multilateralism in Asia—Indonesia, India, and Japan—there is no environment for China to seriously evolve and emerge in as a formidable, lasting, and trusted global leader.

Consequently, what China needs in Asia is not a naval race of 1908, but the Helsinki Process of 1975. In return, what Asia needs from China and Japan is the ‘ASEAN-ization,’ not the ‘Pakistanization,’ of its continent.

 

First published by:

http://thediplomat.com/2017/06/regional-security-architectures-comparing-asia-and-europe/

Author is chairperson and professor in international law and global political studies, Vienna, Austria. He is Editor of the New York-based scientific journal GHIR (Geopolitics, History, Intl Relations). Professors authors four books: FB – Geopolitics of Technology (Addleton Academic Publishers, NY); Geopolitics – Europe 100 years later (DB, Europe), Geopolitics – Energy – Technology (Germany, LAP). Europe and Africa – Security structures (Nova, NY) is his latest, just released book.  His new book is No Asian century.

 

Comments in Chronological order (15 total comments)

Report Abuse
Tue, July 11, 2017 06:07 PM (about 12566 hours ago)
Hey!
I've straight visited this forum benefit of the key outdated and I need a advise advice round penmanship my college essay. Me and my schoolmate
 
Thu, July 13, 2017 02:30 PM (about 12522 hours ago)
Hey!
I'm a unfledged everybody here and I need a passing notice forth writing my college essay. I've got a talk with my friends about how to achiev
 
Thu, August 24, 2017 01:09 PM (about 11515 hours ago)
Keeping a watch out for excellent deals on scuba diving gear may perhaps be something you appear for, ought to you are similar to most scuba diving af
 
Sat, August 26, 2017 03:56 AM (about 11477 hours ago)
Gysiga och medelv?rda individer s?gs ha p? sig sin maxmax 90. Tr?nare ut i foten f?rst, inversely betyder utv?ndig fot en individuell lyx och avfall.
 
Sun, August 27, 2017 09:40 PM (about 11435 hours ago)
The winter wetsuit sale is point you may want to be able to on the lookout for. In the northern hemisphere, winter is known as a time when water sport
 
Wed, September 13, 2017 06:26 AM (about 11042 hours ago)
There has been a recent report that Heath Miller could become a victim of salary cap cuts. If you don't think Warner and Fitzgerald can team up to bea
 
Wed, September 13, 2017 06:26 AM (about 11042 hours ago)
baseball designated for assignment, big east conference, in your eyes lyricsFor both the expert and the newbie baseball gamers that in the wholesale b
 
Wed, September 13, 2017 06:26 AM (about 11042 hours ago)
alex jones, major league gaming, nfl jerseys on sale, bryant universitySan Diego's run of 4 consecutive AFC West titles could be in jeopardy after a s
 
Fri, September 22, 2017 12:56 PM (about 10819 hours ago)
Back to school shopping, what a chore. Shopping for boys is another subject in along with itself. It has been my experience, being the mother of two b
 
Mon, September 25, 2017 03:07 PM (about 10745 hours ago)
The year was 1987. Michael Jordan was about to become the greatest basketball player to ever play the. He was also headed for a kill the basketball dy
 
Mon, September 25, 2017 03:07 PM (about 10745 hours ago)
If you discover a wholesale seller, reduce acquire these Nike shoes for an actually cheaper price. Specific you produce your study while on the net lo
 
Wed, October 11, 2017 11:28 AM (about 10365 hours ago)
What's more, Nike Zoom Kobe 1 is nice and clean of pair of NBA shoes that combined other models. Though we easily know the features of Nike Air Zoom H
 
Thu, October 12, 2017 05:16 AM (about 10347 hours ago)
In the late / efficient at the end of the project: Zoom Air and full of palm oil IPS system provides an incredibly good shock absorber. Shoes carbon f
 
Sat, October 14, 2017 10:57 AM (about 10293 hours ago)
Nike can be a famous manufacturer of shoes which shops prefer as sports gear or the accessories. The Nike shoes are the most recognizable among many b
 
Wed, October 18, 2017 05:31 AM (about 10203 hours ago)
Web stores selling them lure you with heavy discounts, make quick money and disappear altogether. The next day you login to discover a that the webpag
 
Contact Us | About Us | Support Us | Terms & Conditions Twitter Facebook Get Alerts Get Published

All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2002 - 2018