Thu. February 22, 2018 Get Published  Get Alerts
IA-Forum Interview: Rafael Broch, Just Journalism

International Affairs-Forum: Your organization, Just Journalism, researches and analyzes how the UK media portray the Middle East. What have you found to be one of the most common problems with media coverage of the Middle East?

Rafael Broch: One of them is over-concentration on certain subjects, on certain organizations, governments, individuals, and the consequent affect on the public opinion of that concentration. Of course it’s not incumbent on journalists to be concerned with how equitable their coverage is. They don’t have to give equal coverage to every issue. But it can be to the detriment of important issues that do arise in the Middle East. An example: We only very rarely hear about instances of political dissent in Syria in the UK media. That’s not to say they’re not happening, it’s just we don’t hear about those. And of course, some of that is explained, to be fair, by the different levels of access journalists have in those different countries. But there’s very little recognition of that.

IA-Forum: Regarding media coverage of the most recent conflict between Gaza and Israel, can you tell me about some of the trends you have noted and their implications?

Mr. Broch: A lot of these observations are documented in the report we published in February on the subject, which is available online. The first thing to say is the coverage was obviously massive. One of the most positive trends we noted was the approximately equal balance of editorials in the British press on the scale of hostility and favorability toward the military offensive that was going on, which is a good indicator. There were problems; amongst them the failure to distinguish between opinion and factual news reporting. This, of course, influences readers and viewers of the news and can make it difficult sometimes for audiences to reach autonomous or independent views on the subject, so I’m sure you’ll agree that’s relevant.

A couple of other examples were the relatively high levels of reporting that involve the humanizing of individual sufferers in the conflict. Eyewitness accounts and so on. And that obviously has an important emotional consequence for the audiences of the news. A final example is the certain consistencies in the subject matter and also the messages of the political cartoons that were appearing in the British press at the time.

IA-Forum: What is your organization ultimately hoping to accomplish by reporting on the media’s coverage?

Mr. Broch: As a research organization, what we’re trying to do is to collect an evidence base that can hopefully advance the public discussion and debate in the UK, and internationally, about reporting on Israel and the Middle East. Some of the trends we identify and describe in our research raise very important questions about the role of journalism and journalists, what influence they have on public thought, the challenges journalists face in their reporting about the region. And a great deal is written and said on these subjects, but we feel that taking a research-based approach to these important questions and also involving journalists and other media stake-holders too as often as possible in these discussions, their views are obviously essential, is the most valuable approach.

Ultimately, to answer your question, we’d like more awareness of these questions by news consumers and perhaps greater recognition of them by journalists themselves.

IA-Forum: Do you hope to change the behavior of journalists at all?

Mr. Broch: Journalists act independently, and so they should, that’s a very important feature of free media and that’s something to celebrate. So we don’t intend to, I’m not sure how you put it, affect their behavior. We do want to make them aware of some of the issues and we’d like to see them reflect that awareness in their reporting at times.

IA-Forum: Many of Just Journalism’s articles mention the danger of bias in the media. To what extent do you think society is affected by bias in the media? Or is it that the media is affected by bias in society?

Mr. Broch: That’s a good question and I think the short answeris it would have to be that both dynamics here are obviously at work. The interplay between society and the media is deeply complex and to approach the question, it depends on which area and which form of media we’re talking about as these obviously differ widely in terms of their influence and their responsibility. In general, Just Journalism does not address “bias” as a concept, as we think it’s rarely a useful term. People use bias as a detrimental term; but this rarely address the nuances of the questions at stake. For example, do they mean neutrality? Or do they mean balance? Or perhaps they’re making a point about relative concentration by journalists. Bias is used for all of these terms and that’s probably not a great situation. Journalists obviously have a huge influence and a great responsibility in terms of shaping public opinion on the most important questions that society faces, and to a degree they’re of course responding to the societal agenda and what people feel are the priority issues. But they’re also simultaneously shaping it as well. And that’s why collecting data on their outputs, which is what we do, is a small but valuable step to take.

IA-Forum: A June 23 article on the Just Journalism Web site discusses the role of citizen journalism in the recent political protests in Iran. It said journalists were right to use the cell phone videos and tweets they could get because the Iranian government was prohibiting mainstream media coverage. In countries that enjoy a free media, can outlets such as blogs and tweets still be justified as legitimate news sources?

Mr. Broch: Of course. These sources make the media a more democratic place and they give previously unheard voices a platform which is really important, too. These sources also add to the number of channels of information that journalists have. But, this development over the past five or ten years does represent a serious challenge for the mainstream news outlets both financially and professionally as they’re increasingly sidelined by the direct availability of this information. But two of the characteristics of the free media are obviously the availability of these kinds of resources, including blogs and tweets, and also the unrestricted conditions in which journalists can use their resourcefulness to collect and arrange these sources.

But I think your distinction is an important one. In places where the media is systematically restricted, as we saw in Iran, the relative importance of citizen journalism sources grows, and the difficulties of relying on these sources become more pronounced. I can’t think of an argument why they shouldn’t be used in these conditions, but you can argue that their shortcomings ought to be recognized by journalists who use those sources. I’ll give you examples:, the identity of the sources is more obscure than more traditional news sources. Their reliability can be harder to verify and, as we pointed out, they may emanate from communities of a narrower profile. News audiences probably need to know this.

IA-Forum: Mainstream journalists have set guidelines they must adhere to regarding ethics and reliability, such as the National Union of Journalists Code of Conduct. As newspapers decline and the popularity of blogging continues to rise, do you think similar guidelines should or will be imposed on bloggers?

Mr. Broch: It’s difficult to know, very hard to predict, because the media landscape is obviously changing so quickly. In truth, I don’t know enough about some of the interesting proposals that are out there about how this might work. It’s likely that there will be large barriers of enforcement and jurisdiction to overcome as the production and consumption of blogs is totally international. So I don’t think we’re very close to that at this stage, but it’s very hard to know.

IA-Forum: To what extend does Just Journalism research blogs that cover the Middle East? Does the organization have any plans to increase the amount of attention it pays to these media outlets?

Mr. Broch: We probably don’t do enough. One of the things we struggle with is the resource level we have. It’s obvious that the amount of news outlets and stations and blogs and all other kinds of platforms for news is just massive and I can’t think of a number of people who would be sufficient to engage with all of them. But the answer to your question is yes, we ought to be doing more on blogs. We’re certainly in contact with them a great deal but in terms of more analytical monitoring and research, we’ve got one project in place which we’re hoping to turn over in the next three months or so which is directly focused on this subject, but the more we can do on this subject, the better.

IA-Forum: The Chinese government is currently attempting to stop civilian journalism by blocking social networking and micro blogging sites. How long do you think this block will last and will it be successful at stopping civilian journalism?

Mr. Broch: It’s a very interesting question. I’m not an expert on the political conditions in China, so, it’s very, very hard for me to know how long the block will last. From the little information I do have, I understand that the challenges faced by citizens hoping to blog and report freely in China are great and conditions there are very restrictive. I’m not confident I can say more about how likely it is those obstructions are going to be lessened or even grow as time will pass. I think the Olympics are probably an interesting example because the spotlight was very much on China at the time. I’m not sure there’s been a great deal of change since then so I can’t think what would catalyze a very drastic change in increasing the level of freedom of journalists in China. But again, I’m really not an expert.

Rafael Broch is Director of Strategy forJust Journalism, , an independent research organisation focused on how Israel and Middle East issues are reported in the UK media.

Comments in Chronological order (0 total comments)

Report Abuse
Quick Links Twitter Face Book Get Alerts Contact Us Enter Ia-Forum Student Award Competition
02/22/2018: Rebuilding Macroeconomic Theory More
02/22/2018: At emotionally raw White House 'listening session,' Trump reminded himself to say, 'I hear you' More
02/22/2018: Trump declares hoax Russian story hoaxed fake media into covering hoax rallies More
02/22/2018: Mueller files additional charges against former Trump campaign manager Manafort and aide Gates More
02/22/2018: Two USGS appointees resigned because Interior chief wanted to see new oil and gas data in advance More
02/22/2018: Pennsylvania has a completely new congressional map. Our new guide walks you through each district. More
02/22/2018: SCOTUS: When you sue abusive prison guards and win, the guards should get 25 percent of your award More
02/22/2018: Austin official says prison blocked him from abused asylum seeker because he might talk to media More
02/22/2018: Trump administration again proposes the full elimination of home heating assistance to the poor More
02/22/2018: 'We have not declared war on the press,' Sarah Sanders claims, while attacking the press More
02/22/2018: RNC is using a 'slush fund' to pay Trump's former bodyguard $15,000 per month for 'consulting' More
02/22/2018: Disney is using 'tax cut bonus' to try to force union workers to accept low pay More
02/22/2018: Open thread for night owls: ACLU report explores how 21st Century Americans can go to debtors prison More
02/21/2018: Trump takes a hatchet to Obama-era pro-LGBTQ health policies More
02/21/2018: HUGE: Democrats flip Kentucky seat Trump won by 49 points, making this the 37th red-to-blue pickup More
02/21/2018: Olympic biathletes: 'Our country needs to change' on guns More
02/21/2018: Arizona Sen. Jeff Flake will try to force a vote on a plan for Dreamers More
02/21/2018: Have dirt on Trump? For hush money, go to his lawyer ... or the National Enquirer More
02/21/2018: Trump gets back to sabotaging Obamacare More
02/21/2018: Missouri has been paying cash at secret rendezvous for the drug it uses to execute people More
02/21/2018: On the 123rd anniversary of his death, here's an essay by Frederick Douglass on Reconstruction More
02/21/2018: Man featured on dating website for Trump fans was convicted for 'indecent liberties with a minor' More
02/21/2018: Razing Arizona: Republican lawmakers assault independent redistricting commissionAGAIN More
02/21/2018: Open thread for night owls. MacGillis: How pessimism undermines push for stricter gun laws More
02/21/2018: The role of negative trade secrets in the Uber-Waymo settlement - The role of negative trade secrets in the Uber-Waymo settlement More
02/21/2018: Cheers and Jeers: Wednesday More
02/21/2018: Abbreviated Pundit Round-up: Another day in America, which is why the kids are angry More
02/21/2018: Daily Kos Radio is LIVE at 9AM ET! More
02/21/2018: Trump calls to strengthen background checks nine days after his budget cut funding for them More
02/21/2018: Morning Digest: Pennsylvania's new congressional map scrambles the playing field in many races More
02/21/2018: Cartoon: Broken child, grown man More
02/21/2018: Marco Rubio is being called out for having it both ways on guns, and he doesn't appreciate that More
02/21/2018: As FEMA ends its temporary housing program, displaced Puerto Rican families face homelessness More
02/21/2018: Are Europes digital companies paying their fair share? - Agency fees explained | In 60 seconds - AEI More
02/21/2018: Trade Talks Episode 24: The Trump Administration Views Trade as National Security Threat More
02/21/2018: Not just Parkland: Students rise up against gun violence More
02/21/2018: Congressman representing district with Columbine and Aurora nearly boo'd out of town hall over guns More
02/21/2018: A generation of Parkland students is coming for Republican lawmakers More
02/21/2018: Trump keeps tweeting, keeps reminding us how deep Mitch McConnell is in the Russia election hacking More
02/21/2018: Texas school district threatens suspension if students protest to prevent the next mass shooting More
02/21/2018: Man who quit job over ICE thought about his own family: 'I couldnt comprehend us being separated' More
02/21/2018: Immigrant teen credited with saving lives of at least 20 of his fellow Parkland students More
02/21/2018: Pennsylvania Republicans, utterly rejecting democracy, want to impeach judges who ordered new maps More
02/21/2018: Florida House: Porn is a public health risk, assault weapons are not More
02/21/2018: This isn't just a fight between the U.S. and Russiaand what's at stake can't be overstated More
02/21/2018: That time when the GOP was on the wrong side of every movement for freedom in the country More
02/21/2018: Starkville, Mississippi aldermen block residents from holding an LGBTQ pride parade. Buckle up. More
02/21/2018: Florida Republicans really don't want to face students fighting for their lives More
02/21/2018: DACA recipients are educators, nurses and first respondersand they need the DREAM Act now More
02/21/2018: Democrats, you have another shot at the Dream Act. Don't blink this time More
About | Contact Us | Support Us | Terms and Conditions

All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2002 - 2018