Thu. February 26, 2015 Get Published  Get Alerts
HOME  |LOGIN
ABOUT | CONTACT US | SUPPORT US
Frictions in the South China Sea - Chinese strategic mistake

Comments(0)
(Why Indonesia and Japan are pivotal in Asia)


On the eastern, ascendant flank of Eurasian continent, the Chinese vertigo economy is overheated and too-well integrated in the petrodollar system. Beijing, presently, cannot contemplate or afford to allocate any resources in a search for an alternative. (The Sino economy is low-wage- and labor intensive- centered. Chinese revenues are heavily dependent on exports and Chinese reserves are predominantly a mix of the USD and US Treasury bonds.) To sustain itself as a single socio-political and formidably performing economic entity, the People’s Republic requires more energy and less external dependency. Domestically, the demographic-migratory pressures are huge, regional demands are high, and expectations are brewing. Considering its best external energy dependency equalizer (and inner cohesion solidifier), China seems to be turning to its military upgrade rather than towards the resolute alternative energy/Green Tech investments – as it has no time, plan and resources to do both at once. Inattentive of a broader picture, Beijing (probably falsely) believes that lasting containment, especially in the South China Sea, is unbearable, and that – at the same time – fossil-fuels are available (e.g., in Africa and the Gulf), and even cheaper with the help of warships. 1

In effect, the forthcoming Chinese military buildup will only strengthen the existing, and open-up new, bilateral security deals of neighboring countries, primarily with the US – as nowadays in Asia, none wants to be a passive downloader. Ultimately, it may create a politico-military isolation (and financial burden) for China that would just consequently justify and (politically and financially) cheapen the bolder American military presence in Asia-Pacific, especially in the South China Sea. It perfectly adds up to the intensified demonization of China in parts of influential Western media. Hence, the Chinese grab for fossil fuels or its military competition for naval control is not a challenge but rather a boost for the US Asia-Pacific – even an overall – posture. (Managing the contraction of its overseas projection and commitments – some would call it managing the decline of an empire – the US does not fail to note that nowadays half of the world’s merchant tonnage passes though the South China Sea. Therefore, the US will exploit any regional territorial dispute and other frictions to its own security benefit, including the costs sharing of its military presence by the local partners, as to maintain pivotal on the maritime edge of Asia that arches from the Persian Gulf to the Indian Ocean, Malacca and South China Sea up to the northwest–central Pacific.) A real challenge is always to optimize the (moral political and financial) costs in meeting the national strategic objectives. In this case, it would be a resolute turn of China towards green technology, coupled with the firm buildup of the Asian multilateralism. Without a grand rapprochement to the champions of multilateralism in Asia, which are Indonesia, India and Japan, there is no environment for China to seriously evolve and emerge as a formidable, lasting, and trusted global leader warships .

Opting for either strategic choice will reverberate in the dynamic Asia–Pacific theatre. However, the messages are diametrical: An assertive military – alienates, new technology – attracts neighbors. Finally, armies conquer (and spend) while technology builds (and accumulates)! At this point, any eventual accelerated armament in the Asia-Pacific theatre would only strengthen the hydrocarbon status quo. With its present configuration, it is hard to imagine that anybody can outplay the US in the petro-security, petro-financial and petro-military global playground in the following few decades. Given the planetary petro-financial-tech-military causal constellations, this type of confrontation is so well mastered by and would further only benefit the US and the closest of its allies.

Within the OECD/IEA grouping, or closely; the G-8 (the states with resources, infrastructure, tradition of and know-how to advance the fundamental technological breakthroughs), it is only Japan that may seriously consider a Green/Renewable-tech U-turn. Tokyo’s external energy dependencies are stark and long-lasting. After the recent nuclear trauma, Japan will need a few years to (psychologically and economically) absorb the shock – but it will learn a lesson. For such a huge formidable economy and considerable demography, situated on a small land-mass which is repeatedly brutalized by devastating natural catastrophes (and dependent on yet another disruptive external influence – Arab oil), it might be that a decisive shift towards green energy is the only way to survive, revive, and eventually to emancipate.

An important part of the US–Japan security treaty is the US energy supply lines security guaranty given to (the post-WWII demilitarized) Tokyo. After the recent earthquake-tsunami-radiation armageddon, as well as witnessing the current Chinese military/naval noise, Japan will inevitably rethink and revisit its energy policy, as well as the composition of its primary energy mix.

Tokyo is well aware that the Asian geostrategic myopias are strong and lasting, as many Asian states are either locked up in their narrow regionalisms or/and entrenched in their economic egoisms. Finally, Japan is the only Asian country that has clearly learned from its own modern history, all about the limits of hard power projection and the strong repulsive forces that come in aftermath from the neighbors. Their own pre-modern and modern history does not offer a similar experience to other two Asian heavyweights, China and India. That indicates the Far East as a probable zone of the Green-tech excellence and a place of attraction for many Asians in the decade to come.


1 More on the pan-Asian architectures in my 2011 work: “Preventive diplomacy: No Asian century…”



Anis H. Bajrektarevic, Geopolitics of Energy Editorial Member

Chairperson for Intl. Law & Global Pol. Studies

Vienna, 20 MAY 2012


contact: anis@bajrektarevic.eu

Comments in Chronological order (0 total comments)

Report Abuse
Quick Links Twitter Face Book Get Alerts Contact Us Enter Ia-Forum Student Award Competition
International Affairs
Forum - (2014 Issue 1)

Available Now
ANNOUNCEMENTS
THE WORLD'S DISCUSSING...
04/15/2015: Galina Starovoitova Fellowship on Human Rights and Conflict Resolution 2015-16 More
03/02/2015: Resilience for Peace: A New Agenda More
03/02/2015: The Evolution of Ukrainian National Identity in the Crucible of Maidan and War More
03/01/2015: Kennan Institute Pleased to Announce New Fellowship Program More
02/28/2015: How Marijuana Regulation is Affecting Public Attitudes in Uruguay and Elsewhere More
02/25/2015: Sub-Saharan Africa: Energy Security and Growth More
02/25/2015: Dani Rodrik Named Ford Foundation Professor of International Political Economy at Harvard Kennedy School More
02/25/2015: Russia in Free Fall More
02/25/2015: The Revolution of Dignity Art Exhibit: Images from Ukraine's Maidan, 2013-2014 More
02/25/2015: The Russian Threat to Lithuania: An interview with Foreign Minister Linas Linkevicius More
02/25/2015: The Russian Threat to Lithuania: An interview with Foreign Minister Linas Linkevicius More
02/25/2015: A Conversation with Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson More
02/25/2015: African American History Month Special Edition: The Civil Rights Movement in the Shadow of MLK More
02/25/2015: Policy Brief 15-3: Japanese Investment in the United States: Superior Performance, Increasing Integration [pdf] More
02/25/2015: A Greek Deal and What It Means More
02/25/2015: Hillary the Stealth Candidate More
02/25/2015: The agreement with Greece and the challenges ahead More
02/25/2015: The agreement with Greece and the challenges ahead More
02/25/2015: The agreement with Greece and the challenges ahead More
02/24/2015: Delegación salvadoreña expone en EEUU preocupación por Acuerdo Transpacífico More
02/24/2015: President Solís’ popularity declines as economy worsens, Costa Rica researcher tells Washington panel More
02/24/2015: Corruption, inequality remain key issues in Central America's latest election cycle More
02/24/2015: “No esa tonada”, Jose Rubén More
02/24/2015: ¿Un Podemos en el Cono Sur? More
02/24/2015: "Latin America's Electoral Cycle 2014-15" Forum Held at the Wilson Center More
02/24/2015: MENA Women's News Brief More
02/24/2015: How earthquakes affect Dutch politics and natural gas production More
02/24/2015: Argentines March in Downpour to Keep Fernandez on Defensive More
02/24/2015: Early child development for 2030: China's post-MDG plan More
02/24/2015: How to contain Russia without a new Cold War More
02/24/2015: How to contain Russia without a new Cold War More
02/24/2015: Terrorism Poses No Existential Threat to America. We Must Stop Pretending Otherwise More
02/24/2015: I’m an Immigrant and a Reform Advocate. Obama's Executive Actions Are a disaster for the Cause. More
02/24/2015: Using the Internet to promote services exports by small- and medium-sized enterprises More
02/24/2015: BROOKINGS LIVE: President Obama's Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF) against the Islamic State More
02/24/2015: Greece Must Stop Grandstanding and Start Governing More
02/24/2015: President Obama Is Apparently Not Imperial Enough for the GOP More
02/24/2015: How Greece's Creditors Can Encourage Its Return to Stability More
02/24/2015: The Political Assimilation of Immigrants and Their Descendants More
02/24/2015: Tax filing and the Affordable Care Act More
02/24/2015: To Make Men Free: A History of the Republican Party More
02/24/2015: ????? ???????: ?????? ??????????? ??? ???????? ??? ??????? ??????? More
02/23/2015: Greece: An Economic Tragedy in Six Charts More
02/23/2015: Establish a national freight investment program to improve trade and economic performance More
02/23/2015: Burundi's 2015 Elections: Perspectives, Priorities, and Preparations at Three Months Out More
02/23/2015: Free Trade Makes Cancer Drugs Cheaper More
02/23/2015: Maritime Security in the Asia-Pacific Region and the U.S.-Japan Alliance More
02/23/2015: India's Next Budget Needs a Vision for Leading Asia More
02/23/2015: Brazil's prescription: Collaborative diplomacy for a more stable global order More
02/23/2015: Brazil's prescription: Collaborative diplomacy for a more stable global order More
More...
About | Contact Us | Support Us | Terms and Conditions

All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2002 - 2015