Tue. September 23, 2014 Get Published  Get Alerts
HOME  |LOGIN
ABOUT | CONTACT US | SUPPORT US
Syria and the Arab Uprisings: A Special Case

Comments(1)
Initially, only five Syrian protestors stood in al Hamidiya market on March 15, 2011 to protest the murder of young students accused of wearing anti-government graffiti. They shouted in Arabic: ‘we sacrifice our blood and souls for you Syria.’ Since then an estimated 22,000 Syrians, and counting, have been killed by the Assad regime to quell the pro-democracy demonstrations.

Although all Arab Spring countries shared common denominators of external pressure and internal violence, yet Syria remains a unique case because of the Cold War behavior the country conjures from its allies. In some prospects, Syria is seen as a proxy territory by the anachronistic Cold War mentality held by the Russians, Chinese and their allies in the region (most notably Iran). Intervening powers must recognize the interests of Syria’s allies- Russia in particular-in order to stop the bloodshed, remove al Assad, and keep the Arab Spring in blossom.

Russia expresses sensitivity to the developments in Syria recognizing Damascus as one of its few remaining strongholds in the region. In fact, in Tartus Port on the eastern coast of the Mediterranean, under a 1971 agreement, renewed again in 2005, the one and only Russian naval shipping-deck in the Mediterranean is based there. Military analysts doubt the port’s functionality, which could be the case after exploring a few YouTube clips of the port’s old ships; nonetheless, the Kremlin appreciates it as a means to limiting Western influence in the Middle East, let alone a symbolic presence of Russia’s strength and global dominance.

Russia has a big stake in Syria today, not in al Assad by name. Damascus is one of the largest buyers of Russian weapons, third to only Venezuela and India. If Russia were to receive guarantees on military and economic roles in the new Syria, Moscow would be the first to support UN resolutions, and perhaps secretly demand al Assad to relinquish power and leave the country. The memories of Mikhail Gorbachev’s support, after being so reluctant at first, of UN Security Council Resolution 678 of 1990, which demanded Iraq to unconditionally withdraw from Kuwait, provide a base for optimism. Gorbachev’s support, as evidence later on revealed, was made possible through generous Saudi aid [bribe] amounted to four trillion dollars. 1

Likewise, China displays its own concerns fearing that sources of oil in the Middle East could be, for the most part, in the hands of Western states if the Syrian regime were to fall. Beijing worries itself with how authoritarian regimes- being one itself- are swiftly falling apart one after another. The domino effect sweeping the Middle East is real. In this regards, China identifies that overthrowing al Assad, adding to the list of former friends in Iraq and Libya, would possibly pave the path for the West to overthrow Ahmadinejad’s regime, which is of a strategic importance to China for oil imports. As of July, 2012, half of Iran’s oil exports are imported by China, Reuters reported. 2

By the same token, Iran views Syria as the corridor separating the Arab Spring from an inevitable Iranian Spring. Thus, by siding with Assad, Ahmadinejad in fact defends an advanced front. Further, as U.S. calls for Assad to abdicate power grows, the alliance between Tehran and Damascus grows accordingly out of common need, common goals and common cause.

The United States, on the other hand, favors and supports the idea of a Middle East without Assad for a host of reasons to include: backing up its rhetoric of democracy and freedom, acknowledging the concerns of its key regional allies’–in particular Israel, Saudi Arabia and Qatar- in addition to sincere concerns over the spread and leakage of WMDs in an inherently dangerous region.

Certainly, in the heart of Syria’s intractable problem lie disagreements among Russia, China and the United States; however, such discordance is not over the future of Assad. Moscow and Beijing understand that al Assad’s departure is inevitable. The Russian and Chinese discomfort exists in imagining the imminent post-Assad era. This is what stokes the cold war mentality. The continued failure to put an end to the Syrian massacre highlights the imperative need to address the Syrian case with its own merits. This requires a policy move away from treating all Arab protests as a singular unit.

To best abate al Assad is to tackle his sources of strengths and legitimacy: the military, the economy and Russia. After months of fruitless focus on weakening Syria’s military and economy , it is time for intervening powers to place much of their effort on Russia and identify that Syria’s military and economy are subordinates to Russia as an instrument to rid the country of the Assad regime.

1 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8V_wHFSxtcw&feature=related

2 http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/07/17/iran-oil-idUKL6E8IHDPV20120717


Yasir Kuoti
TEL: 715-803-0274
Email: Yasir.kuoti@gmail.com

Yasir Kuoti is an Iraqi freelance writer based in Washington D.C. Mr. Kuoti is a contributor to the Atlantic Community where he writes and comments on the politics of the Arab world.

Comments in Chronological order (1 total comments)

Report Abuse
Tue, May 14, 2013 12:56 AM (about 11940 hours ago)
 
Quick Links Twitter Face Book Get Alerts Contact Us Enter Ia-Forum Student Award Competition
International Affairs
Forum - (2014 Issue 1)

Available Now
ANNOUNCEMENTS
THE WORLD'S DISCUSSING...
09/25/2014: How to Address Child Migration from Central America More
09/22/2014: Should Korea Join the Trans-Pacific Partnership? More
09/22/2014: The Ukraine Crisis: the View from Odessa More
09/22/2014: Teleconference: ISIS, Assad, and the Syrian Opposition: Challenges Confronting US Policy in Syria More
09/22/2014: Deputy Secretary of Energy Daniel Poneman to Give Remarks at The Wilson Center More
09/22/2014: Now for the Hard Part: Renewing Regional Cooperation on Critical Infrastructure Security and Resilience More
09/22/2014: Global Health blog: Making a Home for Hospitals in Global Health: The Global Hospitals Collaborative More
09/22/2014: 2014 Brazil Economic Conference More
09/22/2014: Development blog: Going Beyond Investment to Close the Gender Gap More
09/22/2014: Jane Harman on Face the Nation More
09/22/2014: What to Expect from the UN Climate Summit More
09/22/2014: Development blog: Latest Move against Tax Avoidance Good but Not Great More
09/22/2014: A Six-Point Plan of Action More
09/22/2014: The History of the Future of Syria More
09/22/2014: Event: Should Korea Join the Trans-Pacific Partnership? More
09/22/2014: ONU: Niños migrantes, default, Maduro... More
09/22/2014: INFOGRAPHIC: Interlinked U.S.-China Food Trade More
09/22/2014: Should Korea Join the Trans-Pacific Partnership? More
09/22/2014: Development blog: Why Poor Countries Shouldn’t Imitate Rich Countries’ School Systems More
09/22/2014: The Most Dangerous World Ever? More
09/22/2014: Mapping Europe's Banking System: Most Small Banks Are German More
09/22/2014: Global Prosperity Wonkcast: Hospitals for Health – Amanda Glassman More
09/21/2014: Hans-Werner Sinn: The Euro Trap: On Bursting Bubbles, Budgets, and Belief More
09/20/2014: Is there Hope for Central American Youth? More
09/19/2014: China’s Quest for Safe + Secure Food: Boon for U.S. Business? More
09/19/2014: China Chart of the Week: Services Lead Growth as Industry Slows More
09/19/2014: U.S. Army Corps: Assuring NATO Preparedness More
09/19/2014: U.S. Army Corps: Assuring NATO Preparedness More
09/19/2014: Africa in the News: International Efforts to Stem Ebola Intensify; Peacekeeping Mission in the Central African Republic Transfers to U.N. Leadership; U.N. Agencies Report on Food Insecurity in Africa More
09/19/2014: Paying the Cost of Climate Change More
09/19/2014: Income Tax Changes and Economic Growth More
09/19/2014: The Boys Are Back in Town: Iran's Annual Charm Offensive Begins Amidst Fading Hopes for a Deal More
09/19/2014: Scotland Votes 'No': More Governments Should Follow the U.K.'s Example of Self-Determination More
09/19/2014: Corporate Taxation: Historic Reform Awaits 2017 More
09/19/2014: Policy Brief 14-22: Should Korea Join the Trans-Pacific Partnership? [pdf] More
09/19/2014: Why ISIS Has an Abundance of Modern Weapons More
09/18/2014: CGD Event: The Impact of Secondary Schooling in Kenya: A Regression Discontinuity Analysis More
09/18/2014: Battle to Save the Export-Import Bank More
09/18/2014: Chile como potencia alimentaria y el desafío chino More
09/18/2014: Development blog: “Degrade, Defeat, and Destroy”—But What Will We Build? More
09/18/2014: What’s Next? Celebrating 20 Years of the Environmental Change and Security Program More
09/18/2014: Pakistan’s Biggest Challenge: Turning Around a Broken Education System More
09/18/2014: Central African Republic: Should the World Pay Attention? More
09/18/2014: The Climate Change Summit: Why Humanitarians Should Pay Attention More
09/18/2014: The Climate Change Summit: Why Humanitarians Should Pay Attention More
09/18/2014: Power Paradox in China and India: Seizing Control to Give It Away More
09/18/2014: The Coalition of Convenience More
09/18/2014: Cato Announces Newly Expanded Center for the Study of Science More
09/18/2014: Top 10 Global Hometowns of America's Foreign Students More
09/18/2014: Hutchins Roundup: the Zero Lower Bound, New Model for Capital Regulation, and Income Elasticities More
More...
About | Contact Us | Support Us | Terms and Conditions

All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2002 - 2014