Sat. February 24, 2018 Get Published  Get Alerts
Democracy Versus Dictatorship As Africa’s Best Model of Governance


By Chambers Umezulike

For the proponents of dictatorship as the best fashion of governance for Africa, most African countries are not yet matured for democracy. To them, democratic governance is expensive and economic development is a proviso for political freedom. They fortify their argument through mentioning the governance models and tantivy developmental progress of the United Arab Emirates and China (pseudo dictatorship). For the detractors of dictatorship, development that is not inclusive and a product of repression can never be sustainable.

Africa’s persistent developmental and leadership challenges have continued to accentuate a raging debate, over the best form of governance, for the continent’s political and socio-economic development. Regardless of the low economic development indicators, the continent has continued its predominant dependence on primary exports. In addition, most African leaders have been linked with acute prebendalism, corruption, human rights abuse, developmental-strategies-deficit, and exiguous political will to develop their countries. Most of them have assumed their leadership roles with limited training in the art and science of directing and effectively instituting policies of economic development, despite their resource-base muscle. As such, Africa’s poor development indicators have been primarily attributed to leadership crisis.

The democracy versus dictatorship debate is rooted on several paradoxical factors, both for their proponents and detractors. First is the actuality that some East Asian countries and a considerable number of countries in other regions, that were once considered Africa’s economic comparators in the 1960s and 1970s, were developed by leaders that used the elements of benevolent dictatorship. These leaders were in office between 1960 and 2000; and encompass Yew, Suharto, Mahathir and Park, amongst others. They stayed for few decades in office which ensured policy consistency and an elongated time for them to operationalize their development ideologies, tactics, and strategies. They also made use of strict maximalist strategies to enclose trade unions in a container to ensure predictable labor practices; ensure political stability; and institute birth control regimes to ensure that population explosion didn’t overburden development. For the latter, China and Singapore are shining examples. These leaders played significant roles in the socio-economic development and political emancipation of their countries through harnessing resources and ingenuity of their people for national development.

However, a counter argument to this is that, whereas East Asian countries made use of such governance fashion to develop or become industrialising/industrialised economies, Africa had an assortment of dictators/military rulers at the same time who failed to use arbitrary power to develop their countries. Examples encompass Obote, Sese Seko, Banda, Bokassa, etc. Similarly, for the proponents of dictatorship as a vehicle for the continent’s development, contemporary counter case studies include Mugabe, Museveni, and Nguema, amongst others. These leaders, under pseudo democracies, can be classified as dictators but have not used their peremptory powers to develop their countries while scoring high in several branches of bad leadership.

Secondly is the actuality that while democracy ensures political freedom, inclusion, equality, respect for the rule of law, and protection of human rights, it has been abused by most African leaders. Most of these leaders, such as Deby, Dos Santos, under pseudo democracies, have been amending constitutions to stay longer in power. As such, political power has become concentrated in one political party and finally in the hand of one leader, leading to power personalisation and repression of all forms of opposition. Africa’s democracy is also being characterized by weak electoral institutions, voting along ethnic lines, post-election crisis, rigging, thuggery, god fatherism, as well as other extremely reprehensible practices such as distributing moneys at polling booths during elections.

Furthermore, campaigns have been heavily monetized as politicians share all manner of food items and transport/domestic equipment to lure voters. As a result of this, politicians enter office to embezzle in order to prepare for subsequent electoral cycles. There is still a lack of mechanisms available for citizens to ensure accountability and transparency in the practices of political office holders or even hold them to account, with respect to their campaign promises.

By weighing the arguments and counter arguments for and against the both models of governance, one gets tired of the one that can actually work for the continent. Most African countries have highlighted that democracy finds it difficult to thrive where illiteracy level is high, institutions are weak, civil society is not organized, and in underdeveloped/developing countries. East Asian leaders used benevolent dictatorial power to put these elements in order before they transitioned to democracies. This was during the Cold War era, when the West was busy courting allies as against being a global watchdog for human rights and respect for the rule of law. Africa has lost such a window. At the same time, the world has changed and there is little space for absolute national dictatorships in the current world order.

Africa has the only option of democracy in today’s world. In this respect, it is imperative that the continent strengthens electoral institutions and demonetize politics through gross reduction of campaign costs and monetary benefits of political office holders. The latter will usher in disincentives for the wrong people to go into politics. The civil society has to be strengthened so as to expose governmental corruption, hold leaders accountable on their promises, conduct civic education to enlighten the populace, campaign for the respect of rule of law, and monitor the government on the execution of public policies.

Ultimately, to reduce the cost of governance on the continent, African countries should consider collapsing bicameral legislatures. Then, for improved political inclusion following societal fractionalisation, it is imperative that inexpensive devolution systems are established.

Chambers Umezulike is a Development Expert, Researcher, and Writer. He is currently a programme manager and lead researcher at Connected Development. He has a Masters in International Studies, Economic Governance, and Development from the University of Nairobi, Kenya. He has written 3 books including "Leadership, Policy and Economic Development in Nigeria and Singapore; a Comparative (1960 - 1990).” He also has 2 papers on learned academic journals, with a considerable number of articles on an avalanche of Africa’s political and socio-economic issues on several online platforms and offline newspapers. 

Comments in Chronological order (8 total comments)

Report Abuse
Thu, April 13, 2017 08:12 AM (about 7612 hours ago)
Great read Prof Chambers. I quite see it as a fact rather than a debate. Africans need the Iron Hand Rule - Benevolent dictatorship like you mentioned
Fri, April 14, 2017 12:27 PM (about 7584 hours ago)
Fri, April 14, 2017 05:43 PM (about 7579 hours ago)
?????? ???? ??????????! ??????? ? ??? ????!
????? ???? ? ??????? ?? ???? ?? ???? ?????: :
Fri, April 14, 2017 07:24 PM (about 7577 hours ago)
?????? ???? ?????????? ??????! ??????? ? ??? ????!
????? ???? ? ??????? ?? ???? ?? ???? ?????: :
Fri, April 14, 2017 08:44 PM (about 7576 hours ago)

[url=] [b]Click to Buy Phentermine Online[/b][/url]

Sat, April 15, 2017 12:14 AM (about 7572 hours ago)
Started untrodden snare throw
erotic texting erotic mp4 erotic weight gain erotic themes
Sat, April 15, 2017 12:31 AM (about 7572 hours ago)

??????? ??????? ? ???????? ??? ??????????? ???????? ???????, ??? ?????????? ????????????? ??????? ? ? ????? ????? ????????? ? ?????? ????????!
Sat, April 15, 2017 01:05 AM (about 7571 hours ago)
Lamiderm in hollywood Huft, USA +19492854745 T.Huft, USA S??pe tatyana.huft3. Lamiderm apex jn american health journal 2017
????? ????????? ??? ??
Quick Links Twitter Face Book Get Alerts Contact Us Enter Ia-Forum Student Award Competition
02/24/2018: Cheers and Jeers: Rum and Resistance FRIDAY! More
02/24/2018: Remember Trump's promise to keep protections for people with pre-existing conditions? He lied More
02/24/2018: Companies finally discover the buying power of black consumers and it is nothing to ignore More
02/24/2018: This Week in Statehouse Action: Going for the gold edition More
02/24/2018: One of Trump's ambassador nominees caught lining his would-be boss' pockets More
02/24/2018: What 'Black Panther' actor and DACA recipient Bambadjan Bamba has in common with the superhero More
02/24/2018: Americans want stronger gun laws, another poll finds More
02/24/2018: Open thread for night owls: Court gives thumbs-down on Trump regime's effort to suspend methane rule More
02/24/2018: NRA's Dana Loesch wants us to blame 'people who are crazy' for mass shootings, facts be damned More
02/24/2018: Abbreviated Pundit Round-up: A good guy with a gun didn't stop a bad guy with a gun. Now what? More
02/24/2018: Voting Rights Roundup: Pennsylvania court orders a fair congressional map to replace GOP gerrymander More
02/24/2018: The ultimate Daily Kos Elections guide to all of our data sets More
02/24/2018: Abbreviated Science Round-up: Citizen science, a star is un-born, and more mole rat news More
02/24/2018: When Republicans don't get their way, their solution: Eliminate judgesand the rule of law More
02/24/2018: CPAC comm. director says they chose Michael Steele to chair the RNC because 'he was a black guy' More
02/24/2018: Second victory this week in California for advancing gender equity - AEI - American Enterprise Institute: Freedom, Opportunity, Enterprise More
02/23/2018: Ignore study claiming polluting trucks aren't polluting says prez of university that produced it More
02/23/2018: Obamacare helped breast cancer care in Kentucky, at least until Republican Gov. Bevin ruined it More
02/23/2018: The White House is 'getting away with murder' on security clearances More
02/23/2018: State Department human rights report will put women in their place, Trump administration style More
02/23/2018: A black and white mentality in a world full of color More
02/23/2018: NRA pivots to blaming the media: 'You love mass shootings, crying white mothers are ratings gold' More
02/23/2018: The two men to have booted Jorge Ramos for asking questions: Fidel Castro and Donald Trump More
02/23/2018: Thank you, Trump: Shut down of coal plants accelerates More
02/23/2018: Open thread for night owls. Study finds fracking a major source of carbon pollution in Pennsylvania More
02/23/2018: Morning Digest: Eric Greitens indicted, and Missouri legislature commences investigation More
02/23/2018: Cartoon: Electoral gunsights More
02/23/2018: Abbreviated pundit roundup: Arming teachers is a stupid and dangerous idea More
02/23/2018: Daily Kos Radio is LIVE at 9AM ET! More
02/23/2018: Time for Democrats to go on offense on gun safety More
02/23/2018: Trump plays ventriloquist's dummy for the NRA's Wayne LaPierre More
02/23/2018: The unbelievable magic of Trumponomics - AEI - American Enterprise Institute: Freedom, Opportunity, Enterprise More
02/23/2018: Trump, done with mourning Parkland dead, gets back to taunting Dreamers More
02/23/2018: The media don't love mass shootings, but the NRA absolutely LIVES for them More
02/23/2018: According to a new report, white supremacy had an especially good year thanks to Trump More
02/23/2018: More accountable delegation in health care - AEI - American Enterprise Institute: Freedom, Opportunity, Enterprise More
02/23/2018: No, Trump, arming teachers won't worknot practically, not legally, not ever More
02/23/2018: Rubio suffers serious Twitter burns from a high school student and a veteran turned congressman More
02/23/2018: Trump PAC going all in to save Republican House seat, so lets beat him More
02/23/2018: Luis Ramirez-Marcano dies in ICE custody, third detainee death this fiscal year More
02/23/2018: Here are the companies breaking up with the NRA (and ones that need more encouragement) More
02/23/2018: Former Trump associate Rick Gates is making a deal with Mueller More
02/23/2018: 'Cadet Bone Spurs' has the gall to call the outgunned Douglas High officer a 'coward' More
02/23/2018: Saudi Arabias nuclear energy play - AEI - American Enterprise Institute: Freedom, Opportunity, Enterprise More
02/23/2018: Senate Republicans have no plans to turn Trump's empty talk on guns into action More
02/23/2018: Citing Trump's racist views, Haitian and Salvadoran immigrants sue administration over TPS decision More
02/23/2018: Midday open thread: Missouri loses its supplier of execution drug; 'Working Day of Action' protest More
02/23/2018: The GOP tax law used to be extremely unpopular. Not anymore. - AEI - American Enterprise Institute: Freedom, Opportunity, Enterprise More
02/23/2018: Trump White House economists said some good things about land deregulation. But what about taking action? - AEI - American Enterprise Institute: Freedom, Opportunity, Enterprise More
02/23/2018: Here's the reason Trump tasked the ATF with regulating bump stocksthe NRA practically runs it More
About | Contact Us | Support Us | Terms and Conditions

All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2002 - 2018