X Welcome to International Affairs Forum

International Affairs Forum a platform to encourage a more complete understanding of the world's opinions on international relations and economics. It presents a cross-section of all-partisan mainstream content, from left to right and across the world.

By reading International Affairs Forum, not only explore pieces you agree with but pieces you don't agree with. Read the other side, challenge yourself, analyze, and share pieces with others. Most importantly, analyze the issues and discuss them civilly with others.

And, yes, send us your essay or editorial! Students are encouraged to participate.

Please enter and join the many International Affairs Forum participants who seek a better path toward addressing world issues.
Mon. July 22, 2019
Get Published   |   About Us   |   Support Us   | Login
International Affairs Forum

Around the World, Across the Political Spectrum

Indonesia might be trapped in Chinese debt with the BRI

Comments(76)

By Dr. Muhammad Zulfikar Rakhmat and Dendy Indramawan

The euphoria about the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) in Indonesia has been felt since 2017, particularly following the country’s participation in the BRI Summit in Beijing that year, where Indonesia was expected to receive massive investments from China to support several infrastructure projects.

This year, the debates concerning the BRI are again becoming prevalent after Indonesia’s Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs Luhut Binsar Panjaitan as Indonesia's representative signed 28 BRI projects last April.  Among the various debated subjects is the concern about Chinese debt-trap and Indonesia’s ability to avoid it.

The BRI Chinese debt trap

In the realisation of the BRI, China is targeted to spend US $ 4.4 trillion (Rp 62.7 thousand trillion) which is divided into various infrastructure projects in 65 countries. The funds from China will be disbursed from three main institutions, namely the Export-Import Bank of China, the Asia Infrastructure Investment Bank and the Silk Road Fund. However, the implementation of the BRI caused various kinds of controversy, one of which was related to the fear of a debt trap.

Sri Lanka is one of the BRI participating countries that must give up on China’s debt. The Mattala Rajapaksa International Airport (MRIA) project in Sri Lanka which costed US $ 190 million (Rp 2.7 trillion) with an interest of 6.3 percent did not benefit from the airport's operations.

As a result, the Sri Lankan government is losing money. This made the country unable to pay debts to China. The inability to pay credit or interest, at the end of June 2016, led Sri Lanka to make an agreement with China in the form of equity (surrendering land for lease) for 99 years to the country.

According to a well-known Indian strategic analyst, Brahma Chellaney, what China does with its BRI is a debt-trap diplomacy effort, where this type of diplomacy is a bilateral relationship that is interwoven on the basis of debt. In its operations, this type of diplomacy involves a creditor country that deliberately extends excessive credit to the debtor country. If the debtor country cannot fulfill its debt obligations, often the creditor country will make it possible to interfere with economic and political conditions in the debtor country.

Acknowledging this, Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad in August 2018 said his country would stop funding-backed projects from China, including a railway line worth US $ 20 billion as there is a possibility that the country would be trapped in huge debts.

Indonesia needs to be careful

The same concern is also prevalent in Indonesia, given that the country, in the midst of many of its own problems, the government seemed to be incessantly ambitious to continue to take part in the BRI. It is important to remember that currently Indonesia's external debt has reached US$387.6 billion at the first quarter of 2019.  It consists of government and central bank external debts of US$190.5 billion that have slightly rose by 3.1 percent (year-on-year) and private external debts of US$197.1 bilion that have rocketed by 12.8 percent (year-on-year).

Although the ratio of Indonesia’s external debt to Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is relatively safe at the level 36.9 percent and S&P Global Rating has just raised the long-term sovereign credit ratio for Indonesia from “BBB-“ to “BBB”, the Indonesia’s economic foundation is very fragile.

In 2018, for instance, the massive capital outflow made significant depreciation of the Rupiah against the US dollar due to the hike of Fed Fund Rates and the contagion of Turkish lira crisis. The currency hit about 15,000 rupiah against the greenbacks, the lowest level since the 1998 financial crisis, and made it one of the worst performing currencies in the region.

The extreme volatility of the Rupiah causes payments of interests and foreign debts more expensive. The 1998 financial crisis provided a precious experience that many companies faced default and the country’s economy experience chaos with economic growth of -13.1%. With such conditions, how come Indonesia dear to magnify its debts by signing massive BRI projects?

There is also a concern that the BRI projects is, instead of profiting Indonesia, putting the country at a disadvantage. One example comes from the Palembang LRT project, which has the same potential as the airport in Sri Lanka, is empty with little visitors. In fact, this project must suffer losses with an operating burden of Rp. 8.9 billion (US$618, 545) per month.

By looking at the fact that infrastructure projects have not been able to improve economic growth and to the gap in inequality - especially in the East - as well as various other disputes, the government's decision to sign many BRI projects is certainly questionable. Also ironic is that the implementation of infrastructure development in Indonesia remains suffering from overt corruption practices. Instead of aiming at the welfare of society, infrastructure projects often become fields of concern for interested parties. Overall, there is a possibility that Indonesia will face Chinese debt trap is it is not careful, which would have negative impacts on the Indonesian economy.

The government needs to be able to make sure that participating in the BRI would not led to its loss. As what Malaysia has done, Jakarta may need to renegotiate with China on the terms and conditions of those projects. Indonesia must realise that China needs them more than they need China as the planned maritime route under the BRI would not be realised without Indonesia. Malaysian case demonstrates that negotiation is possible with China. Failure to do the above, it would not be surprising if what happened to Sri Lanka would also happen to Indonesia.

Dr. Muhammad Zulfikar Rakhmat is a lecturer at Universitas Islam Indonesia and a research associate at Jakarta-based Institute for Development of Economics and Finance.

Dendy Indramawan is a research assistant at Jakarta-based Institute for Development of Economics and Finance.

Comments in Chronological order (76 total comments)

Report Abuse
Tue, June 25, 2019 09:23 PM (about 632 hours ago)
? ????????? ???? Qualcomm ????????? SoC Snapdragon 845 ???????? ???????? ????? ??????? ? 2018 ????. ?? ??????? ? 2018 ????, ??? ?????????? ?? ????????
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 03:04 AM (about 626 hours ago)
???? ??????! ?????????? ? ??? ????!
????? ???????? ???? ????: a href=http://kinovalenok.tv/???????? ???????? ???????? ???????? ?????????/a
?????
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 09:05 AM (about 620 hours ago)
allessentialspa.com
a href=http://www.allessentialspa.com/allessentialspa.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 09:34 AM (about 620 hours ago)
http://newsontheflipside.com/
a href=http://www.newsontheflipside.com/www.newsontheflipside.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 09:35 AM (about 620 hours ago)
http://hotworldreport.com/
a href=http://hotworldreport.com/hotworldreport.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 10:02 AM (about 619 hours ago)
www.finance-webtransfer.com.ua
a href=http://finance-webtransfer.com.ua/www.finance-webtransfer.com.ua/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 10:32 AM (about 619 hours ago)
www.wcoinsw.com
a href=http://wcoinsw.com/wcoinsw.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 11:00 AM (about 618 hours ago)
www.krasotamira.com
a href=http://krasotamira.com/krasotamira.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 11:29 AM (about 618 hours ago)
www.topindinews.com
a href=http://www.topindinews.com/topindinews.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 11:59 AM (about 617 hours ago)
http://www.healthmedicinentral.com/
a href=http://www.healthmedicinentral.com/www.healthmedicinentral.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 01:00 PM (about 616 hours ago)
http://www.hotfashionnews.com/
a href=http://hotfashionnews.com/www.hotfashionnews.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 01:00 PM (about 616 hours ago)
http://www.advocatehealthyu.com/
a href=http://www.advocatehealthyu.com/advocatehealthyu.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 01:29 PM (about 616 hours ago)
http://vasedrogerie.com/
a href=http://www.vasedrogerie.com/vasedrogerie.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 01:30 PM (about 616 hours ago)
www.newsaltcoins.com
a href=http://www.newsaltcoins.com/newsaltcoins.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 01:59 PM (about 615 hours ago)
http://bestlifestylebuzz.com/
[url=http://bestlifestylebuzz.com/]www.bestlifestylebuzz.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 01:59 PM (about 615 hours ago)
www.dr-gesundheit.com
[url=http://www.dr-gesundheit.com/]www.dr-gesundheit.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 02:29 PM (about 615 hours ago)
http://www.moviesmylife.com/
[url=http://moviesmylife.com/]moviesmylife.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 02:58 PM (about 614 hours ago)
pediatricradiologynet.com
[url=http://pediatricradiologynet.com/]pediatricradiologynet.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 03:27 PM (about 614 hours ago)
http://aboutcancerservice.com/
[url=http://www.aboutcancerservice.com/]www.aboutcancerservice.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 03:28 PM (about 614 hours ago)
icelebritylove.com
[url=http://icelebritylove.com/]icelebritylove.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 03:57 PM (about 613 hours ago)
http://mental-fitness-group.com/
a href=http://mental-fitness-group.com/www.mental-fitness-group.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 04:28 PM (about 613 hours ago)
www.kingfirthhealthandfitness.com
a href=http://kingfirthhealthandfitness.com/kingfirthhealthandfitness.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 04:30 PM (about 613 hours ago)
sports-life-news.com
a href=http://sports-life-news.com/www.sports-life-news.com/a
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 04:59 PM (about 612 hours ago)
galfinance.com.ua
[url=http://galfinance.com.ua/]galfinance.com.ua[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 05:27 PM (about 612 hours ago)
greenhealthlive.com
[url=http://www.greenhealthlive.com/]greenhealthlive.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 06:54 PM (about 610 hours ago)
www.gesichtspflege-tuch.com
[url=http://gesichtspflege-tuch.com/]gesichtspflege-tuch.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 07:25 PM (about 610 hours ago)
http://jleibach-gesundheit.com/
[url=http://jleibach-gesundheit.com/]www.jleibach-gesundheit.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 07:27 PM (about 610 hours ago)
http://automototale.com/
[url=http://www.automototale.com/]www.automototale.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 08:23 PM (about 609 hours ago)
http://www.binj.in/
[url=http://www.binj.in/]binj.in[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 09:19 PM (about 608 hours ago)
www.loire-net.tv
[url=http://www.loire-net.tv/]www.loire-net.tv[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 10:20 PM (about 607 hours ago)
http://www.bestcelnews.com/
[url=http://bestcelnews.com/]www.bestcelnews.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 10:49 PM (about 607 hours ago)
http://topbollynews.com/
[url=http://topbollynews.com/]www.topbollynews.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 10:51 PM (about 607 hours ago)
http://www.carsradars.com/
[url=http://carsradars.com/]www.carsradars.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 11:19 PM (about 606 hours ago)
http://www.aboriginalhealth.net/
[url=http://www.aboriginalhealth.net/]www.aboriginalhealth.net[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 11:21 PM (about 606 hours ago)
familymednews.com
[url=http://www.familymednews.com/]familymednews.com[/url]
 
Wed, June 26, 2019 11:48 PM (about 606 hours ago)
www.allmyfamilycare.com
a href=http://allmyfamilycare.com/allmyfamilycare.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 01:46 AM (about 604 hours ago)
http://www.celebritycovernews.com/
a href=http://celebritycovernews.com/www.celebritycovernews.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 03:13 AM (about 602 hours ago)
http://crynfiction.com/
a href=http://www.crynfiction.com/www.crynfiction.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 03:43 AM (about 602 hours ago)
novator.io
a href=http://novator.io/novator.io/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 05:12 AM (about 600 hours ago)
http://www.bestallergymedicinehq.org/
a href=http://bestallergymedicinehq.org/www.bestallergymedicinehq.org/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 06:40 AM (about 599 hours ago)
http://www.priority-finance.com.ua/
a href=http://www.priority-finance.com.ua/www.priority-finance.com.ua/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 08:10 AM (about 597 hours ago)
http://newsneednews.com/
a href=http://www.newsneednews.com/www.newsneednews.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 08:33 AM (about 597 hours ago)

Hi there! I simply would like to offer you a big thumbs up for your excellent information you have right here on this post. I am returning to your
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 08:38 AM (about 597 hours ago)
http://ehealthweek2010.org/
a href=http://ehealthweek2010.org/ehealthweek2010.org/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 10:11 AM (about 595 hours ago)
http://fitness-gear-pro.com/
a href=http://www.fitness-gear-pro.com/www.fitness-gear-pro.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 10:41 AM (about 595 hours ago)
www.tokenstalk.info
a href=http://tokenstalk.info/tokenstalk.info/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 12:10 PM (about 593 hours ago)
digiskygames.com
a href=http://www.digiskygames.com/digiskygames.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 12:37 PM (about 593 hours ago)
indibuzzonline.com
a href=http://indibuzzonline.com/indibuzzonline.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 01:08 PM (about 592 hours ago)
http://www.sportstoft.com/
a href=http://www.sportstoft.com/sportstoft.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 02:06 PM (about 591 hours ago)
http://movies-and-tv.com/
a href=http://movies-and-tv.com/www.movies-and-tv.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 05:47 PM (about 588 hours ago)
http://personlichegesundheit.com/
a href=http://personlichegesundheit.com/www.personlichegesundheit.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 06:36 PM (about 587 hours ago)
http://www.gohealthygo.com/
a href=http://www.gohealthygo.com/gohealthygo.com/a
 
Thu, June 27, 2019 10:33 PM (about 583 hours ago)
http://www.travelbaseonline.com/
a href=http://www.travelbaseonline.com/www.travelbaseonline.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 12:29 AM (about 581 hours ago)
www.ecogastropediatria.com
a href=http://www.ecogastropediatria.com/ecogastropediatria.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 01:37 AM (about 580 hours ago)
http://www.aboutcelebritynews.com/
a href=http://www.aboutcelebritynews.com/aboutcelebritynews.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 02:01 AM (about 579 hours ago)
www.highwaytale.com
a href=http://www.highwaytale.com/highwaytale.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 03:10 AM (about 578 hours ago)
www.allmysportsnews.com
a href=http://www.allmysportsnews.com/www.allmysportsnews.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 04:16 AM (about 577 hours ago)
http://celebritytidings.com/
a href=http://celebritytidings.com/celebritytidings.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 05:03 AM (about 576 hours ago)
http://altnewscoin.com/
a href=http://www.altnewscoin.com/altnewscoin.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 06:13 AM (about 575 hours ago)
http://www.beyondfitnessforever.com/
a href=http://www.beyondfitnessforever.com/www.beyondfitnessforever.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 06:13 AM (about 575 hours ago)
www.beautyandcarenews.com
a href=http://www.beautyandcarenews.com/beautyandcarenews.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 08:07 AM (about 573 hours ago)
www.mylifestylemax.com
a href=http://www.mylifestylemax.com/www.mylifestylemax.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 10:24 AM (about 571 hours ago)
http://www.elitacenter.net/
a href=http://www.elitacenter.net/elitacenter.net/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 10:49 AM (about 571 hours ago)
www.svetskii.com
a href=http://www.svetskii.com/www.svetskii.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 12:42 PM (about 569 hours ago)
www.playserver5.com
a href=http://www.playserver5.com/playserver5.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 03:43 PM (about 566 hours ago)
bestfilmstime.com
a href=http://bestfilmstime.com/bestfilmstime.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 07:16 PM (about 562 hours ago)
http://moviesforpeople.com/
a href=http://www.moviesforpeople.com/moviesforpeople.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 07:45 PM (about 562 hours ago)
ourfulltable.com
a href=http://ourfulltable.com/ourfulltable.com/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 08:13 PM (about 561 hours ago)
http://www.lela.io/
a href=http://lela.io/www.lela.io/a
 
Fri, June 28, 2019 08:41 PM (about 561 hours ago)
http://www.toppersonalhealth.com/
a href=http://www.toppersonalhealth.com/toppersonalhealth.com/a
 
Sun, June 30, 2019 08:18 AM (about 525 hours ago)
a href=https://spidermanfarfromhomefull.nethttps://spidermanfarfromhomefull.net/a
a href=https://spidermanfarfromhomemovie.org/https://spidermanfarf
 
Sun, June 30, 2019 09:11 PM (about 512 hours ago)
a href=https://spidermanfarfromhomefull.nethttps://spidermanfarfromhomefull.net/a
a href=https://spidermanfarfromhomemovie.org/https://spidermanfarf
 
Mon, July 01, 2019 11:38 PM (about 486 hours ago)
How to Buy Stuff on Craigslist How to Get Started With. Making wild claims or exaggerating the illness or features of a product only results in
 
Tue, July 02, 2019 04:35 AM (about 481 hours ago)

Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the way, how can we
 
Tue, July 02, 2019 06:09 PM (about 467 hours ago)
Hi, tired of sitting with no money?
I was just a poor student, and now i make 1100$ - 1400$ every day here: http://9binaryoptions.net/uploads/review
 
Tue, July 02, 2019 06:11 PM (about 467 hours ago)
?????? ????! ?????????? ? ??? ????!
????? ?????????? ????: b ?????? ??? ???????? /b a href=http://sportmanlife.ru/http://sportmanlife.ru//a
???:
 
Contact Us | About Us | Support Us | Terms & Conditions Twitter Facebook Get Alerts Get Published

All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2002 - 2019