|
International Affairs Forum asked seven Pakistan experts: "Domestic criticism of Pakistani leader Gen. Pervez Musharraf is growing, and almost six years after military action in Afghanistan began, key Al-Qaeda leaders are believed to be hiding along the border with Pakistan. But does the U.S. have any real choice but to back Musharraf?" |
|
|
Larry P. Goodson, U.S. Army War College
Response: The answer is "No, not really." The U.S. has always chosen to take the short-term view and back the military leader of the moment in Pakistan, for geo-strategic reasons, when the only thing that can ever bring real stability there is a longer term approach that fosters democratic and economic development (at the expense of the entrenched military that now exists there). I was once meeting in Isl... more
|
|
Khalid Hasan, journalist and writer
Response: It is ironic that every time there is an opportunity for the establishment of a genuniely democratic civilian government in Pakistan, the U.S. is found on the side, not of the popular forces working towards that end, but in alliance with those who are on the other side of the divide. This the U.S. does is not because it has a liking for army generals as such, but because the pursuit of its foreign... more
|
|
Satish Kumar, India’s Nat. Security Annual Review
Response: The U.S. policy towards Pakistan shows poor understanding of the nature of Pakistani society and the historical processes which have shaped it. It is based on the assumption that the military of Pakistan being the de-facto ruler can deliver on behalf of America and eliminate terrorist forces from the soil of Pakistan, including the Taliban and Al-Qaeda.
The U.S. government chooses to ignore th... more
|
|
M. Lall & I. A. Lodhi, Institute S. Asian Studies
Response: The current U.S. strategic priorities in South Asia lie with the waging of the war on terror. The logic of this war means that the U.S. needs a foothold in the Afghani-Pakistani border region, and needs most of all to control the Pakistani leadership, which both allows them to maintain this foothold as well as supports American strategic policy.
The first priority of the U.S. is to take out al... more
|
|
The EU Reform Treaty - 9/13/2007
International Affairs Forum asks ten commentators: "What will be the impact of the EU Reform Treaty ... more... |
How serious? - 7/22/2007
"With talk of a new Cold War, and Russian President Vladimir Putin
floating the possibility of aimi... more... |
A new Cold War? - 7/22/2007
International Affairs Forum asked Russia specialists and commentators: "With talk of a new Cold War,... more... |
|
|
|